The story follows the lives of Andrew, an employee at an internet dating site who dreams of meeting the girl of his dreams, and Zelda, a no-nonsense lawyer who was raised by a hippie mother and carries a rebellious streak. By an accidental chance of fate, Zelda meets Andrew to resolve a mismatch dating dispute and these two single people suddenly find themselves falling for each other.

• Ben Feldman
• Cristin Milioti
• Henry Zebrowski
• Lenora Crichlow
• Christina Kirk
• Parvesh Cheena
• Hong Chau
• Katey Sagal